René's URL Explorer Experiment


Title: Incompatible types detected in assignment of `self` to target of type `Self`, when using `Self` only in method body · Issue #14708 · python/mypy · GitHub

Open Graph Title: Incompatible types detected in assignment of `self` to target of type `Self`, when using `Self` only in method body · Issue #14708 · python/mypy

X Title: Incompatible types detected in assignment of `self` to target of type `Self`, when using `Self` only in method body · Issue #14708 · python/mypy

Description: Bug Report When assigning self to a list element, where the list is of type list[Self], mypy will treat self to be incompatible with Self as long as Self does not appear in the method signature. To Reproduce Playground: https://mypy-play...

Open Graph Description: Bug Report When assigning self to a list element, where the list is of type list[Self], mypy will treat self to be incompatible with Self as long as Self does not appear in the method signature. To...

X Description: Bug Report When assigning self to a list element, where the list is of type list[Self], mypy will treat self to be incompatible with Self as long as Self does not appear in the method signature. To...

Opengraph URL: https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708

X: @github

direct link

Domain: github.com


Hey, it has json ld scripts:
{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"DiscussionForumPosting","headline":"Incompatible types detected in assignment of `self` to target of type `Self`, when using `Self` only in method body","articleBody":"**Bug Report**\r\n\r\nWhen assigning `self` to a list element, where the list is of type `list[Self]`, mypy will treat `self` to be incompatible with `Self` as long as `Self` does not appear in the method signature.\r\n\r\n**To Reproduce**\r\n\r\nPlayground: https://mypy-play.net/?mypy=latest&python=3.11&gist=124fa26ca946c7ae040c43d788a694cb\r\n\r\n```python\r\nfrom typing import Self\r\n\r\n\r\nclass A:\r\n    def __init__(self) -> None:\r\n        self.siblings: list[Self] = []\r\n\r\n    def insert(self, index: int):\r\n        self.siblings[index] = self  # this fails\r\n\r\n    def insert__no_return(self, index: int) -> None:\r\n        self.siblings[index] = self  # this fails\r\n\r\n    def insert__return(self, index: int) -> list[Self]:\r\n        self.siblings[index] = self  # this does not fail\r\n        return self.siblings\r\n\r\n    def insert__annotate_self(self: Self, index: int):\r\n        self.siblings[index] = self  # this does not fail\r\n\r\n    def local_variable(self) -> None:\r\n        l: list[Self] = [self]  # this fails\r\n        l[0] = self  # this fails\r\n\r\n    def local_variable__return(self) -> list[Self]:\r\n        l: list[Self] = [self]  # this does not fail\r\n        l[0] = self  # this does not fail\r\n        return l\r\n```\r\n\r\n**Expected Behavior**\r\n\r\n- No errors. \r\n- Assigning `self` to a target of type `Self` should obviously work (or am I missing something here?)\r\n- returning the list and specifying the function return type should not change the behavior \r\n- specifying the type of `self` to be `Self` should not change the behavior\r\n\r\n**Actual Behavior**\r\n\r\nMypy detects imcompatible assignments:\r\n```\r\nmain.py:15: error: Incompatible types in assignment (expression has type \"A\", target has type \"Self\")  [assignment]\r\nmain.py:18: error: Incompatible types in assignment (expression has type \"A\", target has type \"Self\")  [assignment]\r\nmain.py:28: error: List item 0 has incompatible type \"A\"; expected \"Self\"  [list-item]\r\nmain.py:29: error: Incompatible types in assignment (expression has type \"A\", target has type \"Self\")  [assignment]\r\nFound 4 errors in 1 file (checked 1 source file)\r\n```\r\n\r\n**Maybe it's actually undefined behavior?**\r\n\r\nDigging deeper, it looks like [PEP 673](https://peps.python.org/pep-0673/#use-in-method-signatures) lists examples of what are valid or invalid use cases of the `Self` type. It explicitly states that\r\n\r\n> \"Self used in the signature of a method is treated as if it were a TypeVar bound to the class\"\r\n\r\nThis definition would not cover my example above, as it does only fail if `Self` has been used in _only the body, but not the signature_. On the other hand, this case is listed neither as a positive or negative use case; it is not covered at all by PEP 673, but all examples show that the intention of PEP 673 was to _avoid_ having to explicitly state a signature of `self: Self`, as that would state the obvious.\r\n\r\nThus, considering PEP 673, it might be undefined behavior?\r\n\r\nOn the other hand, following [PEP 484](https://peps.python.org/pep-0484/#annotating-instance-and-class-methods):\r\n\r\n>  the first argument of class and instance methods [...] is assumed to have the type of the containing class for instance methods [...]\r\n\r\nI guess that's the old definition and does not include how to apply `Self`. It would explain mypy behavior - at least to some end. If this were the explanation, then mypy should actually fail or at least warn about incorrect usage of `Self` in `__init__` and `local_variable`. With `Self` being treated as a special case if and only if it appears in method signatures, it does not make sense to use it at those places; at least I cannot think of a use case. I do believe that it is not intended to be used on its own. Thus, an explicit warning, or even an error, would be very helpful in this case.\r\n\r\nSo is this a bug in mypy or is it something that actually simply strictly follows PEP definition? In the second case, I would still consider my example code to be desirable behavior and would be happy to get some hints on how to make this behavior become part of python typing definitions :)\r\n\r\nOr if you would think that this would not be desirable, i'd be happy to learn about your rationale.\r\n\r\n**Your Environment**\r\n\r\n- Mypy version used: 1.0.0\r\n- Mypy command-line flags: none\r\n- Mypy configuration options from `mypy.ini` (and other config files): installed mypy in a fresh virtualenv, no manual configuration\r\n- Python version used: 3.11.2\r\n\r\n","author":{"url":"https://github.com/noresistence","@type":"Person","name":"noresistence"},"datePublished":"2023-02-15T14:40:29Z","url":"https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708"}

react-profiling0
react-import-mapreact,react-dom,react-dom/client,react-dom/profiling,react-is,react/compiler-runtime,react/jsx-dev-runtime,react/jsx-runtime,scheduler@b8488ee2c322
route-pattern/_view_fragments/issues/show/:user_id/:repository/:id/issue_layout(.:format)
route-controllervoltron_issues_fragments
route-actionissue_layout
fetch-noncev2:8d6d5ac6-f0d4-e463-720f-7f922559a3e5
current-catalog-service-hash81bb79d38c15960b92d99bca9288a9108c7a47b18f2423d0f6438c5b7bcd2114
request-idC1A2:1B0A31:1929A8A:21E56F8:6AFFF7E8
html-safe-noncee2fee5c15e28c14e718251ca35c072ba7023ea5863e71dcf533fbad45efae074
visitor-payloadeyJyZWZlcnJlciI6IiIsInJlcXVlc3RfaWQiOiJDMUEyOjFCMEEzMToxOTI5QThBOjIxRTU2Rjg6NkFGRkY3RTgiLCJ2aXNpdG9yX2lkIjoiNjE4OTQ1MjA4NzU4ODI4ODQ4OCIsInJlZ2lvbl9lZGdlIjoiaWFkIiwicmVnaW9uX3JlbmRlciI6ImlhZCJ9
visitor-hmac69fa6cf49fcfe5479132724b797d28d517a856532da5be656549f1752fc11955
hovercard-subject-tagissue:1585977641
github-keyboard-shortcutsrepository,issues,copilot
google-site-verificationApib7-x98H0j5cPqHWwSMm6dNU4GmODRoqxLiDzdx9I
octolytics-urlhttps://collector.github.com/github/collect
analytics-location///voltron/issues_fragments/issue_layout
fb:app_id1401488693436528
apple-itunes-appapp-id=1477376905, app-argument=https://github.com/_view_fragments/issues/show/python/mypy/14708/issue_layout
twitter:imagehttps://opengraph.githubassets.com/ed5b0bc732cdd320d5dc7f647afddfd3db35d097c78b1dffeb61447154075198/python/mypy/issues/14708
twitter:cardsummary_large_image
og:imagehttps://opengraph.githubassets.com/ed5b0bc732cdd320d5dc7f647afddfd3db35d097c78b1dffeb61447154075198/python/mypy/issues/14708
og:image:altBug Report When assigning self to a list element, where the list is of type list[Self], mypy will treat self to be incompatible with Self as long as Self does not appear in the method signature. To...
og:image:width1200
og:image:height600
og:site_nameGitHub
og:typeobject
og:author:usernamenoresistence
hostnamegithub.com
expected-hostnamegithub.com
None0a0d8686a27478df474dd7415776a7a080cde8838b3cd92ea7601187572e5729
turbo-cache-controlno-preview
go-importgithub.com/python/mypy git https://github.com/python/mypy.git
octolytics-dimension-user_id1525981
octolytics-dimension-user_loginpython
octolytics-dimension-repository_id7053637
octolytics-dimension-repository_nwopython/mypy
octolytics-dimension-repository_publictrue
octolytics-dimension-repository_is_forkfalse
octolytics-dimension-repository_network_root_id7053637
octolytics-dimension-repository_network_root_nwopython/mypy
turbo-body-classeslogged-out env-production page-responsive
disable-turbofalse
browser-stats-urlhttps://api.github.com/_private/browser/stats
browser-errors-urlhttps://api.github.com/_private/browser/errors
release16a11879678aaf97e2a42c33ee70830aa084fa37
ui-targetfull
theme-color#1e2327
color-schemelight dark
react-app-nameissues

Links:

Skip to contenthttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#start-of-content
https://github.com/
Sign inhttps://github.com/login?return_to=https%3A%2F%2Fgithub.com%2Fpython%2Fmypy%2Fissues%2F14708
GitHubRepository hosting, code review, and collaborationhttps://github.com/platform
CopilotAI coding agent for tasks, projects, and automated workhttps://github.com/features/copilot
ActionsCI/CD and automationhttps://github.com/features/actions
Code QualityQuality analysis, fixes, and enforcementhttps://github.com/features/code-quality
CodespacesCloud development environmentshttps://github.com/features/codespaces
Code SecurityVulnerability detection and remediationhttps://github.com/security/advanced-security/code-security
Secret ProtectionSecret scanning and leak preventionhttps://github.com/security/advanced-security/secret-protection
All Featureshttps://github.com/features
Documentationhttps://docs.github.com/en
Traininghttps://learn.github.com/skills
Certificationshttps://learn.github.com/credentials
Build with Copilothttps://github.com/features/ai
Customize Copilothttps://docs.github.com/en/copilot/how-tos/copilot-on-github/customize-copilot/customize-copilot-overview
Integrationshttps://github.com/marketplace
Trending reposhttps://github.com/trending
GitHub Sponsorshttps://github.com/open-source/sponsors
Developer articleshttps://github.com/resources/articles
ChangelogYour source for the latest features, improvements, and fixes across GitHub products, all in one place.https://github.blog/changelog/
Enterpriseshttps://github.com/enterprise
Teamhttps://github.com/team
Startupshttps://github.com/enterprise/startups
Nonprofitshttps://github.com/solutions/industry/nonprofits
Healthcarehttps://github.com/solutions/industry/healthcare
Financial serviceshttps://github.com/solutions/industry/financial-services
Manufacturinghttps://github.com/solutions/industry/manufacturing
Governmenthttps://github.com/solutions/industry/government
See all industrieshttps://github.com/solutions/industry
Why GitHubhttps://github.com/why-github
Customer Storieshttps://github.com/customer-stories
Business insightshttps://github.com/solutions/executive-insights
Trust Centerhttps://github.com/trust-center
GitHub Advanced SecurityEnterprise-grade code securityhttps://github.com/security/advanced-security
Copilot for businessEnterprise-grade AI featureshttps://github.com/features/copilot/copilot-business
Premium SupportEnterprise-grade 24/7 supporthttps://github.com/enterprise/premium-support
Documentationhttps://docs.github.com/en
Resource centerhttps://github.com/resources
Bloghttps://github.blog/
Events & webinarshttps://github.com/resources/events
Community Forumhttps://github.com/orgs/community/discussions
Customer Storieshttps://github.com/customer-stories
Integrationshttps://github.com/marketplace
Customer supporthttps://help.github.com/
Traininghttps://learn.github.com/skills
GitHub Statushttps://www.githubstatus.com/
Abouthttps://github.com/about
Partnershttps://github.com/partners
Changeloghttps://github.blog/changelog/
GitHub UniverseThe event for developers, by developers — talks, workshops, and what’s next for GitHub.https://githubuniverse.com/
Pricinghttps://github.com/pricing
Sign inhttps://github.com/login?return_to=https%3A%2F%2Fgithub.com%2Fpython%2Fmypy%2Fissues%2F14708
Sign uphttps://github.com/signup?ref_cta=Sign+up&ref_loc=header+logged+out&ref_page=%2F%3Cuser-name%3E%2F%3Crepo-name%3E%2Fvoltron%2Fissues_fragments%2Fissue_layout&source=header-repo&source_repo=python%2Fmypy
Reloadhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
Reloadhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
Reloadhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
pythonhttps://github.com/python
mypyhttps://github.com/python/mypy
Codehttps://github.com/python/mypy
Issues2.7k (2.7k)https://github.com/python/mypy/issues
Pull requests547 (547)https://github.com/python/mypy/pulls
Actionshttps://github.com/python/mypy/actions
Projectshttps://github.com/python/mypy/projects
Wikihttps://github.com/python/mypy/wiki
Security and qualityhttps://github.com/python/mypy/security
Insightshttps://github.com/python/mypy/insights
https://github.com/python/mypy
New issuehttps://github.com/login?return_to=https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
New issuehttps://github.com/login?return_to=https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
Incompatible types detected in assignment of self to target of type Self, when using Self only in method bodyhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#top
bugmypy got something wronghttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22bug%22
topic-self-typesTypes for selfhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22topic-self-types%22
https://github.com/noresistence
noresistencehttps://github.com/noresistence
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#issue-1585977641
https://mypy-play.net/?mypy=latest&python=3.11&gist=124fa26ca946c7ae040c43d788a694cbhttps://mypy-play.net/?mypy=latest&python=3.11&gist=124fa26ca946c7ae040c43d788a694cb
PEP 673https://peps.python.org/pep-0673/#use-in-method-signatures
PEP 484https://peps.python.org/pep-0484/#annotating-instance-and-class-methods
noresistencehttps://github.com/noresistence
bugmypy got something wronghttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22bug%22
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-8526813255
noresistencehttps://github.com/noresistence
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-8526848290
https://github.com/davfsa
davfsahttps://github.com/davfsa
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#issuecomment-1432044274
mypy/test-data/unit/check-selftype.testhttps://github.com/python/mypy/blob/0bbeab8b26825ee94b8fdeda16f2aa589be4282d/test-data/unit/check-selftype.test#L1695-L1697
0bbeab8https://github.com/python/mypy/commit/0bbeab8b26825ee94b8fdeda16f2aa589be4282d
mypy/mypy/semanal.pyhttps://github.com/python/mypy/blob/0bbeab8b26825ee94b8fdeda16f2aa589be4282d/mypy/semanal.py#L979
0bbeab8https://github.com/python/mypy/commit/0bbeab8b26825ee94b8fdeda16f2aa589be4282d
AlexWaygoodhttps://github.com/AlexWaygood
topic-self-typesTypes for selfhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22topic-self-types%22
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-8530535076
https://github.com/AlexWaygood
AlexWaygoodhttps://github.com/AlexWaygood
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#issuecomment-1432047697
#14075https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14075
AlexWaygoodhttps://github.com/AlexWaygood
Automatically use Self type even if it doesn't appear in method annotation #14075https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14075
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-8530542066
AlexWaygoodhttps://github.com/AlexWaygood
not plannedhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aclosed%20archived%3Afalse%20reason%3Anot-planned
on Feb 15, 2023https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-8530542111
KevinRK29https://github.com/KevinRK29
on Sep 16, 2025https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708#event-19731854383
Typeshed cherry-pick: Make type of `unitest.mock.Any` a subclass of `…https://github.com/python/mypy/commit/ca5abf09f3bfc543ac9c18a364696bc5da20bc03
ca5abf0https://github.com/python/mypy/commit/ca5abf09f3bfc543ac9c18a364696bc5da20bc03
Sign up for freehttps://github.com/signup?return_to=https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
Sign in to commenthttps://github.com/login?return_to=https://github.com/python/mypy/issues/14708
bugmypy got something wronghttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22bug%22
topic-self-typesTypes for selfhttps://github.com/python/mypy/issues?q=state%3Aopen%20label%3A%22topic-self-types%22
https://github.com
Termshttps://docs.github.com/site-policy/github-terms/github-terms-of-service
Privacyhttps://docs.github.com/site-policy/privacy-policies/github-privacy-statement
Securityhttps://github.com/security
Statushttps://www.githubstatus.com/
Communityhttps://github.community/
Docshttps://docs.github.com/
Contacthttps://support.github.com?tags=dotcom-footer

Viewport: width=device-width


URLs of crawlers that visited me.